Page Nav

HIDE

OTG Style Fixes — Nov 11

Ads Place

Menace II Society (1993) — This Is the Truth. This Is What's Real.

How it came to the screen

Menace II Society, released in 1993, is the first feature by Allen and Albert Hughes, and one of the hardest, most unsentimental of the early-90s Los Angeles crime pictures. Issued through New Line, it stars Tyrin Turner as Caine, with Larenz Tate as O-Dog, and a supporting world that includes Jada Pinkett, Bill Duke, Charles S. Dutton, and other faces who keep the film from becoming only a two-hander. The Hughes brothers were very young, and the film has the force of a debut that already knows what it does not want to do: it does not want to comfort you, and it does not want to turn the neighborhood into a lecture or a music video. It wants to follow a young man's options as they narrow.

What you're watching

The story begins with a robbery and a killing that the film stages with a coldness a lot of first-time viewers still remember, and then it watches Caine try, and often fail, to step out of the life that killing belongs to. Tate's O-Dog is the more volatile friend, a character the movie is unwilling to soften into a type with a hidden heart of gold. Pinkett's Ronnie is one of the film's possible exits, a grown presence and a child in the house, a chance the plot will not automatically honor. Duke and Dutton, as older men, give the film a sense that the neighborhood has already lived several versions of this story. The camera is tight, the violence is sudden, and the moral weather is uninterested in a redemption that has not been earned.

Compared with Boyz n the Hood, which is often paired with it in conversation, Menace is colder and less paternal. That comparison is useful if it stays specific. Singleton's film is about fatherhood and a possible path. The Hughes film is about the difficulty of a path, told with a younger, harsher hand. Both are 1991–1993 Los Angeles objects. They are not the same object.

After it opened

The film was a critical and commercial success for a debut, and it became a long-running home-video fact, quoted and rewatched, sometimes reduced to its most shocking scene and then, on a fair rewatch, restored to a complete and carefully made feature. The Hughes brothers went on to other films. Several of the young actors became later official names. Menace II Society remains the first feature that still has to be on the list when people talk about the early-90s cycle honestly, not only the more comforting titles in the cycle.

Why it still matters

It matters because it is a serious debut, still hard to shake, and because it refuses a cheap exit. On a modern disc, the 1993 Los Angeles of the film has a complete runtime, and the performances still have their original force. If you collect the crime pictures of that era, this is one of the essential hard titles, a first film that did not ask to be liked first.

Read the story on the network: Boyz n the Hood (1991) | Baby Boy (2001)

Get It on Amazon

Format: Blu-ray. This link goes straight to the product page.

Buy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

No comments

Latest Articles